Cult Pens x Caran d'Ache 849 Ballpoint Pen Review

(Jeff Abbott is a regular contributor at The Pen Addict. You can find more from Jeff online at Draft Evolution and Twitter.)

The Caran d'Ache 849 ballpoint pen is a classic design that catches nearly everyone's eye. It's prevalent enough to be seen on Amazon, but still difficult to discover unless you happen to be in the right circles with the right browsing and shopping habits for a recommendation to pop up. Once you see one, it's easy to see why they're popular due to the unique barrel shape and vibrant color options. Plus, they're not terribly expensive in terms of premium ballpoint pens.

The 849 I have the pleasure of using today is a custom color provided by Cult Pens. The dark blue on the pen matches their online branding, but it also happens to look particularly handsome on this hexagonal body. Aside from the color, you won't find any other differences on the pen itself to distinguish itself from the regular lineup of color options. But, it does come in a nice case that features a hinge and small magnets that keep it shut. It's satisfying to open and close, and I just couldn't bring myself to throw it out even though I have a pretty ruthless rule of always throwing out or recycling packaging. The case is the only object that has any branding on it, with a prominent "Cult Pens" logo on the top side of the tin.

For the uninitiated, the 849 is a fantastic ballpoint pen, and it also comes in a variety of other formats as well, including mechanical pencil and fountain pen. Across the lineup, the design language is identical. They all feature the sleek hexagonal body with a smooth tapered cone. The body is uniform in color and is one solid piece, so the only accents come from the recognizable clip and the nock on top. In most models, these are a shiny chrome color, but you'll see some slight variance (like a completely black version) in some models. There is some small branding on the body of the pen: a small "SWISS MADE" stamp between the top of the clip and the nock, and a small "849 Caran D'Ache" logo underneath the clip arm. It's easy to miss if you aren't paying attention, and I've always enjoyed the minimal branding on this lineup of writing instruments.

So, if the body is one piece, how does one access the refill? Great question! To swap out the refill, you unscrew the nock. The entire retractable mechanism/assembly comes out and then you can just tilt the pen forward to drop out the refill. Thankfully, the spring inside the body stays in place when gravity would otherwise pull it out of the pen, undoubtedly getting lost on the floor. To reinstall the refill, just drop it into the body, put the retractable assembly back in place, push the nock down and twist slightly to let the threads gain a hold, and then screw it back down until it's tight. It's definitely a unique method for switching refills, but I love it if it means the pen body is one piece!

Speaking of the refill, Caran d'Ache uses their own proprietary refill for these pens — the Caran d'Ache Goliath. It's roughly the same size as a standard Parker-style refill, but it uses a proprietary ink formula. The ink is actually really good, and it's come to be one of my favorites. It always has a little trouble with cold starts after being stored for more than a day, but once it starts writing after a couple of squiggle lines, it's smooth, dark, and consistent. It's one of those dependable refills that never lets you down, and I love it for that. You can swap in a standard Parker-style refill in this pen even though the refills aren't the same length. The Parker ballpoint tip protrudes an extra millimeter or two in this pen, but you could either ignore it, or trim it down fairly easily. This is an easy way to use different types and colors of inks in this pen since Caran d'Ache only offers Fine, Medium, and Bold styles of Black, Blue, Red, and Green ink in their Goliath line.

The Caran d'Ache 849 by Cult Pens is a fantastic ballpoint pen for any occasion. It's a super dependable pen at a great price, and you really can't beat the unique aesthetic the 849 offers.

(Cult Pens provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

---

Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Sharpie Pen S-Gel 0.7 mm Pen Review

Back to School season often brings new pens to the store shelf. While Sharpie’s newest entrant, the S-Gel, has been around for months, only over the summer did we seem them infiltrate the stationery world at scale.

I grabbed a 4-pack of 0.7 mm pens from Amazon (two black gel, one each of blue and red,) to test, but if my grocery store shelves are any indication, you should be able to easily find them in the 0.5 mm and 1.0 mm tip sizes as well. Sharpie’s new Roller is also available as part of the big push we are seeing from the brand.

As many of us pen addicts already know, and as Sharpie is about to find out, the long-time stalwarts of the gel pen section of the store occupy that space for a reason. The Pilot G2, Uni-ball Signo, and Pentel EnerGel are household names, so Sharpie has their work cut out if they want to displace any or all of that trio.

So how does the Sharpie S-Gel stack up against some of the best gel ink pens of the past decade? Not very well.

The worst thing a pen can be is inconsistent, and that is what I am getting from this batch of pens. The black 0.7 mm is especially poor, with a nose cone I can feel scratching the page as the tip rolls across it. This makes for a scratchy, wide line, and a poor experience.

The blue gel pen is the antithesis of the black. In fact it is quite good and reminds me of the Pilot G2, which is a good experience to shoot for. The red gel pen is close to the blue - a little more scratchy, but nowhere as bad as the black.

With the variance I am seeing between the three colors and how they feel on the page, I would be hesitant to recommend these over any of the three excellent choices I mentioned above.

Being under the Sharpie umbrella gives these pens a leg up in marketing, but the performance isn’t there. I think the style is lacking a bit as well. I understand that making a great $2 gel ink pen at scale is difficult, but how about letting loose a little bit?

Sharpie doesn’t hesitate to do that with their permanent marker lineup. How about bringing some of that aesthetic into the gel pen world, instead of designing a pen that looks like every other pen it is competing against? Or maybe design something completely different and off the wall. We already have what they are trying to sell us, and better versions at that.

---

Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Scribo Feel Amarena Fountain Pen with Fine Flex Nib: A Review

(Susan M. Pigott is a fountain pen collector, pen and paperholic, photographer, and professor. You can find more from Susan on her blog Scribalishess.)

Scribo is an Italian company founded by former employees of Omas. Their signature pen is the Scribo Feel, which originally came in two colors: grey-blue and blue-black. Recently, they've expanded their colors, one of which is a rich burgundy called Amarena.

The Scribo Feel comes in a grey-blue box with a magnetic closure. It folds up to reveal a cotton/leather pen case, which can hold two pens and has a pocket with a soft cleaning cloth.

The pen is large, measuring 5.9 inches/150mm capped and 5.31 inches/135mm uncapped. Supposedly it can be posted, but the cap doesn't feel secure posted and it makes the pen unwieldy. Capped it weighs a solid 31.87 grams; uncapped it weighs 20.62 grams (both weights were measured with the pen inked). Although the pen is large, the grip is only 11.32mm, which makes it comfortable in the hand. I like girthy pens, and the Scribo's shape and size suits me perfectly. People with small hands or who prefer lighter pens should try this pen in person before purchasing.

The Amarena is made of burgundy resin hand turned from a single rod. There are twelve facets, which are meant to evoke a Doric column. In addition, both the cap and barrel have convex shapes called entasis, also derived from columns.

Ruthenium accents adorn the pen. The cap finial is a ruthenium coin with a quill inscribed on the surface.

The spring-loaded clip curves to match the cap.

The cap ring is engraved with "Scribo" and "Feel the Writing."

Another slim ring adorns the barrel above the piston knob. The piston mechanism is metal.

Uncapped, you'll notice a distinct drop from the barrel to the grip section. This does not create any discomfort, however, because the barrel of the pen rests between your thumb and pointer finger and your fingertips settle near the nib.

The piston mechanism works smoothly and the pen holds 1.4 ml of ink.

This pen has a 14k ruthenium plated fine flex nib and an ebonite feed. It's not the most beautiful nib, engraved with "Feel the Flex" and "Scribo." I'd prefer scrollwork or the minimalist design of the old Omas nibs.

The nib itself is excellent. It writes smoothly with or without flex and offers generous ink flow.

This is an example of writing without flex:

The fine line without flex expands to about 1mm with flex. It's possible that you could get an even broader line if you pressed harder, but since this pen is on loan, I didn't want to risk it. The pictures that follow demonstrate writing with flex.

I wanted to compare the Scribo flex nib with my vintage celluloid Montblanc 146, which has an oblique medium flex nib, because flex-lovers always want to know how modern flex nibs compare to vintage ones.

As you'd expect, the Montblanc nib is considerably softer than the Scribo nib. Plus, because the Montblanc is a medium nib, it starts with a wider line unflexed so it doesn't demonstrate as much variation when flexed.

The Scribo nib is pretty darn good. It flexes to about 1mm, and bounces back quickly. Because it starts fine, the variation between the line when the nib is unflexed and when it is flexed is much more obvious.

Both nibs performed well when I did calligraphy (please forgive the shaky lines--I'm still learning):

I am pleased with how well the Scribo flex nib performed. I encountered absolutely no railroading or skipping, even when flexing the nib. The nib doesn't feel mushy like the Omas flex nibs. It's bouncy and offers good feedback when flexed.

I've been wanting to try the Scribo Feel ever since it was announced, so I was thrilled when Vanness sent Pen Addict the loaner pen. I wouldn't hesitate to buy one of these pens straight away . . . if they weren't so expensive. The Scribo Amarena with flex nib costs $760. That's a pretty penny for a resin fountain pen. But you are getting a piston filler (with metal threads) and a beautifully designed fountain pen with excellent ink capacity and a flex nib.

I'm debating about purchasing a Scribo Feel. Now that they are offering more choices of color and material, I may succumb to the temptation. It's a well-crafted pen and the flex nib is superior.

You can purchase Scribo Feel fountain pens from Vanness Pens in Amarena, Mediterraneo (teal green), Blue-Black, Grey-Blue, or Grigio-Notte (grey with black trim).

(Vanness Pens loaned this product to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

---

Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!